Skip to content
Prawn Cocktail Tartlets with Marie Rose Sauce
Recipe by Jodie Smith

Prawn Cocktail Tartlets with Marie Rose Sauce

Serves6 people
Prep25 min
Jump to recipe
Shop the pantry

Confiletas Mini Savoury Round Pastry Cases x 12

$9.95

Hand-packed and dispatched from our Corio, Victoria warehouse, with free delivery Australia-wide on orders over $100.

Prawn cocktail tartlets are the whole dish shrunk to one bite: chopped cold prawns in a Marie Rose sauce, spooned into 37mm pre-baked savoury pastry cases. Twelve of them take about 25 minutes, nothing goes near the oven, and the step that decides whether they work is the one that takes the water out of the prawns before they meet the pastry.

Four wet things in a bowl

A prawn cocktail is prawns, sauce, lettuce and lemon, and all four of them are wet. In a glass that is the appeal. Our prawn cocktail with spicy mango and kaffir lime leans on exactly that. The sauce pools at the bottom, the lettuce keeps the prawns cold, you eat it with a fork and nothing has to hold its shape. Move the same four things into pastry and each one turns into a problem. The sauce runs to the base and softens it, shredded lettuce goes limp within the hour, and lemon juice thins mayonnaise until it will not sit on a spoon.

So the recipe below is the same flavour with the water taken out at the source. The chopped prawns are salted and drained in a sieve for 10 minutes before they meet anything else. The lemon goes into the sauce as zest and comes back as juice only at the end, squeezed over the finished tray. The lettuce leaves the dish altogether and returns as one small inner leaf of baby cos tucked in at the edge, where it stays crisp because nothing is sitting on it. What is left is a cold, thick, pink filling that stays where you put it.

Why 37mm decides the chop

The Confiletas mini savoury round cases measure about 37mm across and come twelve to a $9.95 pack, baked and ready to fill. At that size the case will not take a whole prawn, and trying to make it is what undoes most seafood canapes. The tail hangs over the rim, the guest takes a bite, and the rest of the prawn goes on the floor.

Cut each peeled prawn crossways into three instead. The pieces stay curved and pink and still read as prawn from across a room, which a fine dice does not. A medium cooked king prawn gives three pieces of about a centimetre, and three or four pieces fill a 37mm case to the rim. That works out at 200g of prawn meat for twelve tartlets, or roughly 400g of whole prawns once the heads and shells are off. If you would rather hand round a prawn whole, the shell that takes one is the 75mm vol-au-vent, which is what our prawn and avocado vol-au-vents are built on. The Confiletas range covers both ends of it.

Method

Method

  1. Peel the prawns. Twist off the head, unwrap the shell, take the tail off as well, and lift the dark vein out of the back with the tip of a knife. Four hundred grams of whole prawns gives you the 200g of meat this needs.
  2. Cut each prawn crossways into three and leave the pieces as they fall, curved and roughly a centimetre. Resist going smaller. A fine dice turns the filling into a paste and the tartlet stops looking like a prawn cocktail.
  3. Toss the pieces with the fine salt and tip them into a sieve set over a bowl. Leave them for 10 minutes. A tablespoon or so of cloudy liquid should collect underneath, and that liquid is what would otherwise end up in the pastry.
  4. Spread the prawns on paper towel and pat them dry on both sides. Do not rinse the salt off. It has already gone into the meat and it is most of the seasoning.
  5. Stir the mayonnaise, chopped relish, mustard and lemon zest together until the colour is even, adding the Worcestershire if you are using it. Taste it now, before the prawns go in, because this is the only easy point to fix it. It should be a shade sharper and saltier than you want the finished tartlet, since cold food flattens seasoning.
  6. Fold the prawns through the sauce. It should coat them and go no further. If sauce is pooling in the bottom of the bowl, add a few more prawns rather than pouring any off. Cover and keep it cold.
  7. Open the pack of cases at this point and not before, and set them straight onto the platter you are serving from. Filling them in place saves carrying twelve loaded shells across a kitchen.
  8. Spoon a heaped teaspoon into each case, three or four pieces of prawn at a time, filling to the rim rather than above it.
  9. Tuck a small baby cos leaf in at the edge of each one, or scatter the chives. Finish with a pinch of paprika, a grind of black pepper and a squeeze of lemon over the whole tray at the last moment. Serve within the hour.

Questions about prawn cocktail canapes

What is Marie Rose sauce made of?

Mayonnaise, tomato, an acid and a little heat, in roughly that order of quantity. The restaurant version is usually built on tomato ketchup with lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce and a pinch of cayenne, and older recipes add a splash of brandy. Starting from a tomato relish instead of ketchup brings the vinegar in with the tomato, so the sauce needs no extra juice, and no extra juice is exactly what makes it behave inside pastry.

How many prawn tartlets do you need per person?

Two each when a meal follows and these are one of four or five things going round, which is what a pack of twelve is built for. Our canape guide puts that at 4 to 6 pieces a head in the first hour. If the finger food is the meal it moves to 10 to 14 a head over two to three hours, about two thirds savoury, so 7 to 9 savoury pieces each. Make these three of that number: a party of twelve wants 36 tartlets, three packs of cases and 600g of prawn meat.

Do the prawns really need salting and draining?

For a bowl, no. For pastry, yes. A cooked prawn is mostly water and a cut prawn leaks from every cut face, so a filling mixed straight off the chopping board is noticeably looser 20 minutes later, and it is the pastry base that absorbs the difference. Ten minutes in a sieve with half a teaspoon of salt pulls out a tablespoon or two, seasons the meat while it is at it, and is the difference between an hour on the table and twenty minutes.

What else fits these cases if prawns are out of budget?

Anything thick and cold. Cold-smoked salmon over lemony cream cheese is the closest thing to this tray, and the smoked salmon version uses the same case and the same timing, so the two trays can be built side by side and the fish counter's price on the day decides which. Leftover prawn filling is lunch either way: on buttered brown bread, or piled onto crackers with the last of the lemon. It will not keep past the next day and it does not freeze.

The cases are the part worth ordering before December, since they keep in the cupboard for months at $9.95 a pack. Confiletas mini savoury round pastry cases come twelve to a pack, and the rest of the Confiletas range travels in the same order. Shipping is free Australia-wide on orders over $100, and orders placed before 12pm on a weekday are dispatched the same day from our Corio, VIC warehouse, tracked with Australia Post.

Products in this recipe

Cook more of this

New recipes, first.

Recipes, new arrivals and gourmet gifting ideas from The Gourmet Pantry. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Salt the chopped prawns and drain them in a sieve for 10 minutes before they go near the sauce. That water is what softens a pastry base, and taking it out early buys you an hour on the table instead of twenty minutes.

Loved by thousands. Rated 5 stars everywhere.

Real reviews from real customers on Trustpilot, Facebook and Google.